Many Jamaican restaurants in Brooklyn, NY have unique jerk sauce recipes and serve generous portions. With so many options, it’s difficult to choose which Jamaican restaurant to try, especially if you’ve never had Jamaican food before.

 

Common dishes you’ll find at Jamaican restaurants are jerk chicken, oxtail, and Jamaican style fried chicken. Beverages are usually different from those at American restaurants. You’ll find juices and Jamaican alcoholic drinks. Below we have listed nine of the best Jamaican restaurants in Brooklyn based on customer ratings and quality of food.

1. Glady’s

With over 200 reviews with a high average rating, Glady’s is one of the best Jamaican restaurants in Brooklyn. It has unique interior decor, including plants and light blue walls, that helps set a Caribbean atmosphere. The large windows allow a lot of natural sunlight inside the restaurant.

 

As expected of a Jamaican restaurant, you’ll find jerk chicken, oxtail, curry goat, and plantains on the menu. Glady’s offers takeout and delivery, giving you the option to eat at home. Several drinks you could order at the restaurant include Red Stripe lager, roots tonic, and Jamaican rum.

 

Address: 788 Franklin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238.

2. MangoSeed

Popular items on MangoSeed’s menu include jerk chicken, the trio mac, braised oxtail, and sweet plantains. Other good options include jerk salmon, fried chicken, and jerk fish tacos. MangoSeed is one of the highest rated Jamaican restaurants in Brooklyn for atmosphere and service. They are also praised for excellent food.

 

MangoSeed has a fun atmosphere with loud music. It’s a good choice for exciting nights out and spending time with friends. Jermaine Burrowes and his brother Paul Burrowes established MangoSeed in 2009. Their goal is to provide customers with delicious Caribbean cuisine, ambiance, and hospitality.

 

Address: 757 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11226.

3. Rowe’s

Rowe’s is one of the best Jamaican restaurants in Brooklyn that is set up as a casual counter. Jamaican items on their menu include jerk chicken, curry goat, and patties. Wait times at this casual joint are low with the peak wait time around 15 minutes. Customers have praised Rowe’s for good customer service and food. Rowe’s serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner. The restaurant is family-friendly as well.

 

Address: 310 Tompkins Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216.

4. C&J Jamaican Restaurant and Bakery

C&J Jamaican Restaurant and Bakery is one of the best Jamaican restaurants in Brooklyn that offers pastries and cakes. They serve jerk chicken, curry chicken, stewed chicken, oxtail, and other Jamaican meals. The eatery often has long lines but service is prompt considering the number of people in line. Customers have given C&J Jamaican Restaurant and Bakery high reviews for flavorful food and good portions.

 

Address: 817 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203.

5. Good Hope Jamaican Restaurant

As a fast food style restaurant, Good Hope Jamaican Restaurant is ideal for takeout and quick meals. Their jerk chicken, macaroni and cheese, goat curry, and fried chicken are popular items on the menu. They use a unique blend of spices in their macaroni and cheese that you can’t find at another restaurant. Good Hope Jamaican Restaurant has a small sitting area inside for those who want to dine in. During busy times, however, you might not find a seat available.

 

Address: 1683 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11210.

6. Buff Patty

Buff Patty is a homey Jamaican restaurant with a small dining area. As the name suggests, Buff Patty sells patties. Other delicious items on the menu include jerk chicken, oxtail, curry goat, and brown stewed chicken. Sylvester Davis, the founder of Buff Patty, opened the first location in Brooklyn in 1997. In 2004, he opened another location in Long Island.

 

Buff Patty offers catering services of their main dishes, starters, sides, and desserts. Examples of desserts you can enjoy at this restaurant are spice buns, bulla cake, and hard dough bread.

 

Address: 376 Myrtle Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11205.

7. Footprints Cafe

If you’re looking for an exciting night out, the Footprints Cafe is a nice choice in Jamaican restaurants. It’s one of the best Jamaican restaurants in Brooklyn that has live entertainment and sleek surroundings. Footprints Cade has a night club vibe, helping it stand out among other Jamaican restaurants in Brooklyn. Jamaican items on the menu include mini beef patties, escoveitch king fish, plantains, oxtail, jerk chicken, and curry goat.

 

Interesting menu items that are hard to find at other Jamaican restaurants are the Blue Mountain ginger lime chicken, risotto arrabiata with jerk chicken, and jerk chicken club sandwich. Refreshing beverages on the menu include sorrel, ginger beer, cucumber juice, and lemonade. The first Footprints Cafe was opened in 2001. Since then, Robert Gordon has opened two more locations.

 

Address:

• 1521 Surf Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224.
• 5814 Clarendon Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11203.
• 1377 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11210.

8. Golden Krust

Golden Krust is known for authentic Jamaican patties. Other delicious items on their menu include jerk chicken, curry chicken, and oxtail. Golden Krust strives to offer outstanding customer service. They list their company values as fun, integrity, and value. The restaurant also offers franchisee opportunities for people who want to start their own Golden Krust.

 

Address: 139 Lawrence St, Brooklyn, NY 11201.

9. Sally’s Restaurant

Sally’s Restaurant is one of the best Jamaican restaurants in Brooklyn that offers homemade juice as drinks. Some of their popular menu items are fried chicken, goat curry, and jerk chicken. The casual eatery has short wait times, so you receive your food quickly. Other meals worth trying at Sally’s restaurant are the oxtail, brown stewed chicken, curry shrimp on a bed of pasta, king fish, and escoveitched fish.

 

Address: 1574 Ralph Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11234.

Final Thoughts

The nine restaurants listed above are some of the best Jamaican eateries in Brooklyn. All of them are known for having good jerk chicken, one of the most popular dishes from Jamaican cuisine. You can explore other Jamaican food at many of these restaurants as well, such as oxtail, escoveitched fish, and curry goat. Have you tried a Jamaican restaurant in Brooklyn? Let us know where you ate and whether or not you would recommend it.